Posted by: The Paris Apartment | October 13, 2009

Can’t believe the hype


I admit to being a bit of a tree hugger. We’re all trying to do our part to make the world greener and are at point where we’ll do anything if we think it will help. But what happens when a product comes along that we’re told will do the trick, but actually does more harm than good?


(photo from The New York Times)

In a veiled attempt to conserve energy, some dangerous plans have been set into motion that could cause damage to our air and water supplies in a very short time.

One of the last things George Bush did before he left office was to institute the change from incandescent light bulbs to fluorescents (also known as CFLs), a mandatory, forced switch out, by 2010.

The world’s biggest producer of the new bulbs and advocate for the change is General Electric, one of the largest polluters on the Political Economy Research Institute’s Toxic 100 index. The index is based on EPA Toxics Release Inventory data which ranks the nation’s largest companies based on the quantity of their emissions, relative toxicity of chemicals emitted.


Have you ever broken a lightbulb? Of course, we all have. Millions of us.

It was not a big deal with the the innocuous incandescent light bulb. There were no vapors, no dangers, no chance of real harm. Now we’re being told to replace all our light bulbs (throw them in a landfill)! with fluorescent spiral bulbs which are harmful in many different ways we’re only beginning to understand.


That said, I’m all for saving energy and look at ways to conserve all the time. But when I started researching these bulbs, I found that they’re not really green at all, in fact, just the opposite. This is is a case where the bulbs are being touted as safe, yet they’re being produced in a way that’s environmentally unsafe or for the workers who manufacture them and at the same time are extremely inefficient to produce and deliver.
Turns out it takes much more energy to create the new compact fluorescents in every way. The mercury required to make them in the first place and that spills when they break, can be threatening to our health. I read the packages and saw nothing about the dangers on GE’s boxes. No warning, no cautions and no disposal methods. This sign is supposed to be posted where the bulbs are sold.


Mercury vapor has been linked to neurological problems, kidney failure, tremors, insomnia, headaches and neuromuscular changes. These vapors are especially harmful to brains of fetuses and children and severe damage to the central nervous system and liver are possible if it’s absorbed through the skin or inhaled.

If the owner of a broken bulb doesn’t know there are precautions to take in the clean up, they could cause an epidemic and contaminate their family and community. If someone happens to wash bedding or clothing it breaks on, (instead of throwing all of it away, again, not too green), it will send contaminates directly into the community water system. What’s going to happen when these bulbs break in hundreds (or millions) of homes? Walmart’s already sold over 100 million of them.

The cleanup advice itself is not green at all, as it involves everything from plastic bags to duct tape, not to mention having to throw away anything it shattered on, the dustpan and brush, gloves and mask as well, all creating more garbage and waste. You can’t clean it up with a broom as it will spread the mercury through the house, endangering children and pets.


In some states you can put the broken bulb in your outdoor trash and leave someone else to deal with it at the landfill. Or you can dispose of them at your local toxic waste dump, ( if you’re lucky enough to have one of those in your area)! If it’s put with the recycling, mercury can contaminate those who sort it. Those that end up in landfills will, naturally, they’ll be crushed and release mercury into the soil. Ikea and Home Depot will take them for you if happen to have one nearby and want to make the effort. But we only recycle 1% of what’s renewable now, so what are the chances, especially in underdeveloped nations where changes are forced on citizens?

Just how green is any of this? It’s not. At all. GE and Phillips other big producers would like to see everyone smash their old light bulbs and proclaim freedom while they hold up the twisty alternative as a green gift from heaven. Meanwhile they misinform and enlighten us with their green website initiative which glosses over the dangers.


None of this is helping the environment and is creating more toxic waste, using more energy and putting the world’s water in danger. To add insult to injury, they’re not even made in the US! Worst of all, the entire crusade is being spearheaded by GE who closed factories in Virgina and Ohio among others, and moved production to China where workers are being compromised. In factories where CFLs are made, mercury spillage is common during the manufacturing process, and workers are often exposed to deadly chemicals. Massive clean-up bills are accumulating to decontaminate factories and surrounding areas where CFLs were made. With spillages happening regularly, the long term health of the workers are of course, at risk.

The inefficiency of these bulbs is probably the biggest farce. One of the selling points is that they don’t give off heat, yet, in the winter, we’re advised to change back to regular bulbs to save on heating bills as incandescents add warmth to a room and help regulate thermostats. CFLS don’t work in extreme cold, can’t be dimmed, (so they have to run at full power at all times) and will fail prematurely if switched on and off many times a day. Therefore people tend to leave them on all day. Regular lights would otherwise be switched off, so now a household might have 4 or 5 of these CFLs running for hours at a time, where they may have had only 1 or 2 incandescent lamps switched on (and possibly on dimmers), therefore reducing power significantly.

Venezuela, Australia, Canada, and Cuba are trying to make this the legal standard and phasing out the regular light bulb. Phase-outs are also pending in California, New Jersey and other states as well as the European Union.

Michigan Sen. John Gleason introduced legislation on June 12 that would, if enacted, criminalize the sale of incandescent bulbs in the state beginning in 2012 !

So before we go quietly into the night and get on the bandwagon, can you please take a look at the real consequences of bringing something so dangerous into our homes that would be government mandated? And think about whether we’re going to let the world tell us that what they’re proposing is better than what we have without knowing the truth. The concern is not for the environment. GE has 119 US contaminated areas they haven’t cleaned up yet and are starting to leave their trail in China and Taiwan now.

I’m all for a free market but I don’t want my fate hanging in the balance when a neighbor tosses out a deadly CFL grenade.

I personally don’t want to live in a fluorescent world which is why I started to research the topic. What I’ve been discovering is unnerving and painful to think about. But we have to make our own decisions, not let the government tell us how to live.

While we’re working toward a more sustainable future for the environment, we have to consider the cost to humans and the planet, not only of the bulb we pull from the shelf. We have to consider the raw materials it will now take to produce them. The components and the labor and the shipping and the electricity and the outsourcing and the packaging it costs to make them are exponentially higher. Consumers have to consider this carefully. It’s easy to believe that the governments of the world have assessed and researched and determined what “greener” purchases we should make. But the truth is they were lobbied heavier than at any time in history for this switchover and the homework just wasn’t done.

Until governments world-wide can ensure that proper safeguards and decent safe working conditions are a requirement for “environmentally friendly” products, these products should simply be banned from sale.

Please join me in boycotting these bulbs until we have more information about the damage they’re doing. The links on the blogroll have my sources and other extensive data research. Please check them out. Time is off the essence as they’re trying to make this happen by spring of next year while they think we’re not looking.



  1. Claudia. Magnificent blog. Such an important topic. I had no clue. The fact that mercury is so harmful (I remember the fear as a child…my Mom saying don’t drop that glass thermometer…there’s mercury in it). Thank God we have plastic thermometers now.

    To think that these lightbulbs are being touted as “energy-saving” and “being green” is a farce. They don’t show the warning that you posted.

    We need to get active in this, which you’ve started. Perhaps start a petition or something. So, so scary.

    Thanks for the helpful info. Will share wherever I can. Going to Facebook now…

    • What about the alternative to the CFL, ESL (Electron Stimulated Luminescence)? I have only just learned of it and I’m hoping that they have nothing to do with General Electric.
      I too see a train wreck with CFLs and hopefully it is not an intended one, but I have no trust in a company such as GE. They have acquired a crippling rate of cancer that exudes from their facilities. I would also be weary of when the government steps in and makes a huge decision to switch over to a certain kind of light bulb, not really leaving us with choices. Question everything, and in the meantime, turn off your lights when you’re not using them.

  2. Oh wow~ what an informative post! Thanks to “watchdogs” like you, hopefully others will gain knowledge about this highly controversial light bulb. I always thought they were SO ugly and wouldn’t have one in my home but I had no idea how much harm they can cause. And I feel kind of bad for saying this but I don’t trust anything made in China! I’ll definitely spread the word.

    And I love your blog and have owned your book for years now…. The Paris Apartment! Love it!

  3. Claudia,
    Thank you for the time you have put into researching this subject. I have a very close friend who uses nothing but these bulbs, and I know that she would be shocked and horrified to know how dangerous these bulbs can be if broken in her home.


  4. Hi Claudia,
    I am so excited about this new blog and I thank you for spreading the word on this topic! I had no idea and I am so glad that you shared this info. I changed all of my bulbs thinking I was doing something great for the enviroment and my family and it turns out the opposite is true. I can’t believe that with a small child in our home I have these. Please let me know what I can do to help you spread the word and for anything else you can think of. We need to do something. Thanks again Claudia.

  5. Wow that is really outdated information! You should try posting relevant information that helps your readers make informed decisions.

    • Adam, what info do you have to share? I don’t see anything Claudia posted outdated. Do a Google search on the topic and I think you’ll see that she’s totally accurate. You just give a wiki link about the bulb facts…written by people like yourself. Now, who’s the expert?

  6. Thanks for coming by everyone, this blog is meant to serve as a forum and stir some thought on the subject. I don’t claim to be an expert and had no idea about this when I started the blog a couple days ago.
    Adam, I went to your link Wiki link but didn’t see anything of revelation. Can you give me something to back up your claim that this is outdated? I’d love to hear about your most recent findings.

  7. Forget Adam and his ilk. They are always ready to come out of the woodwork with their dubious bits of knowledge gleaned from information they’ve stumbled onto. Wikipedia? Give me a break!

    • Actually I’m really interested in the naysayers…I’d like to see real evidence contradict the facts. This particular comment had nothing to it but I hope someone might. I’d love to be wrong and believe that GE is really looking out for us!

  8. Hi Claudia,

    I sure appreciate you having this new blog for everyone to have a place to discuss the Compact Fluorescent Lights. My husband and I both get headaches everytime we walk thru a grocery store or retail store that has overhead fluorescent lights. It is so bad for me that I literally have to hold on to a shopping cart, just to get thru these stores. If, I do not hold on, I feel very dizzy and start to feel like I will fall to the ground. It feels like my head is being tassered. My husband worked for an Electric Company and heard many complaints from customers complaining about getting headaches that they felt were caused by fluorescent lights.I feel that studies should be conducted to show the harmful effects of fluorescent lights! If this is “Going Green” count us out!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Thank you again Claudia for giving people a place to discuss this issue.


  9. Hi Mary,
    Thanks so much for your comment. I’ve noticed that many pro-bulb articles ignore the ills that people are experiencing, calling them untrue or stating that there’s no ‘evidence’. I hope that your condition is taken seriously and will allow others to diagnose something that may be happening to them. I just read someone ask about headaches their kids were experiencing but it was dismissed as a myth and fallacy, like it couldn’t possibly be true!

    I’m sure there are many stories like these that are going to be brushed off as ridiculous. I hope more people share their stories.

  10. Claudia,

    You rock!
    I sincerely appreciate you going to all the effort to ask people to simply think through
    their so called green choices. It’s not enough to talk the talk, we must also walk the walk
    and face the responsibility of educating ourselves enough so we can make meaningful choices.
    The mass market blind faith that has allowed the organic movement to turn into a multibillion dollar scam that often does more harm than good has similarly gone on way too long.

    Hopefully the feeble haters will not deter you from continuing to try to just spread a little light.

  11. I have these in my house!!!!! I never would of guessed. I can’t believe companies are allowed to hide or cover truths. We as humans and Americans should know everything in the products we use and put in or around our bodies. This world is getting scarier and scarier. Thank you for sharing this…so much for trying to be green!

  12. Hi Sandy,
    Now that you have them, if you like them use them if you can stand the light they give off. The trouble is going to be when they burn out. You can take them to home depot for recycling. I’d be interested in seeing what they do with them all there though and what happens after that.

  13. .Thank you.
    Admirably organized re the green hype! But Humanity: Of utmost importance is how do you FEEL in a fl lit space? Doctors who do healing with different colors of light generated through beneficial crystals will note that cube-farm and Wallmart people spend their day under light generated by mercury and bromides, i.e. cumulatively poisonous toxins. Does that drag you down day after day?

  14. You’re so right about the way these make you feel and the worst part is that we’re told that those who get seizures or headaches are wrong, that the bulbs do not contribute to that.
    I’m also concerned about the excess energy it takes to create these bulbs from production to disposal. Once buildings switch to CFLS, they throw away perfectly good incandescents which is so not green.
    The CFLS are being pushed on the consumer by a GE lobby to replace every light bulb in the world with these new ones. It’s a surefire way to profit and they don’t have our best interests in mind, only their bottom line.
    If you look in Target or Walmart, you’ll see every bulb is made in China except for the few incandescents still on the shelves that were made in Ohio until they closed the plants.
    As consumers, the only way we can stop this dangerous product (from the Mercury, to the vapors, to the Toxic Waste Disposal), is to tell our president that we will not be forced to live in a fluorescent world because companies like GE mask going green with their bottom line.

  15. I’m on board, C! My dad’s an architect, and Im sending it to him, and bombarding him with this info in person just as soon as I can bend his ear….maybe it will only manifest as a small change with some smaller commercial buildings he’s working on, but it only takes one, right?

  16. Thanks, Milda, you’re the best, and right…it starts with one mind at a time!

  17. […] Credit: Environmental Works & Stop at the Green Light Please bookmark and […]

  18. […] Photo Credit: Environmental Works & Stop at the Green Light […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: